For our group presentation, we deiced to compare Amazon’s Kindle Fire tablet released at the end of Septmember, to the recently released in the beginning of November, Barnes and Noble Nook tablet. We decided to compare the Fire to the Nook instead of Apple’s Ipad because the Ipad would just simply blow every other tablet in the world away due to its strong brand name, features, and its Apple operating system. The three social media tools we used were Social Mention, Twitter Stream Graph, and Tweetfeel.
Social Mention showed us that the Kindle Fire had 33% strength, 8:1 sentiment, 44% passion, and 32% reach. The Fire’s strength, which is the likelihood that the brand is being discussed in social media, wasn’t too surprising to me because I personally didn’t even know that there were newer Kindle tablets released until we did this project. The sentiment, which is ratio of positive to negative feedback, was good to hear because the ratio was 8 to 1. So following every negative comment, there were eight positive comments following it. That’s good for a product that’s only been out for a couple months. Passion, which is people talking about the brand repeatedly seemed at a fair level to me because it almost hit about half, where people were talking about the brand over and over again. And finally, reach, which is the percentage of people the company’s actually caught attention to about the product seemed kind of low. Maybe it’s due to the product only being out for a couple months. But with the constant change in technology these days, I’m surprised it was higher.
Twitter Stream Graph showed that for the Kindle Fire, the top key words were; black, deal, and Amazon. Black and deal were the main keywords due to the date in which we looked at the graph, Nov 28th, Cyber Monday. Black Friday was only a few days before which could explain why deal and black were keywords. Amazon is self-explained since it’s the creator of the Kindle. Twitter Stream Graph showed that for the Nook, the top key words were; Barnes & Noble, tablet, and gift. Again, Barnes & Noble and tablet are not surprising to see since Barnes & Noble created the Nook which is a tablet. As I stated before, with Black Friday and Cyber Monday in the past weekend, it’s a great opportunity to buy those gifts for your friends and family for cheap.
TweetFeel for Fire showed 70% and the Nook: 74%. This shows that the Nook had more positive comments said about it. Although the Nook had a higher percentage, this doesn’t mean that it’s overall better than the Fire. For example, TweetFeel captures when someone mentions either the Kindle Fire or Nook and whether there’s a good or bad comment attached to it. But in some comments, for example, “Yay, my Kindle Fire arrived! But it’s uncomfortable to use without resting it down unless your hands are big.” Here, although the person comments, yay for the Fire, they also complain that it’s not easy to handle without hesitation. TweetFeel doesn’t take this into account and therefore accepts it as a positive comment which could throw off the entire data set.
Overall, the Fire has 29% more passion and 8% more strength. However since the Nook just came out at the beginning of November, it’s still in the new product stage where everyone buys it and it doesn’t present problems till about a couple months after its been released. That’s when people start to bash it online and complain about things wrong with it. Although both are powered by Andriod, I still don’t know which tablet I would choose for myself. I personally don’t do a lot of reading so maybe a Kindle Fire would be good for me. But am I willing to spend the extra $50 for it? I guess it’s something we’ll have to see as Christmas approaches.

